I've always had a soft spot for midsize pickups. They're the 'Goldilocks' of trucks—not too big, not too small, and just right for most of us. Over the past few years, I've watched this segment grow from a niche to a serious contender, especially for families who need one vehicle that can do it all. The 2021 model year was a turning point. It gave us a mix of old-school workhorses and new-age comfort cruisers. Now, in 2026, I'm looking back at that class with fresh eyes, and I still think those trucks taught us some valuable lessons. Here's my personal rundown.

my-2026-take-on-the-2021-midsize-pickup-class-image-0

GMC Canyon: Comfort Comes at a Cost 🛋️

The Canyon was always the 'nice' one. It offered a bit more comfort than its rivals, but honestly, it also cost a little more. The diesel option was tempting, but it added $5,000 over the quicker, more powerful V6. For 2021, it also lost the manual transmission, which was a bummer for folks like me who still enjoy rowing their own gears. The interior was genuinely plush, though. If you wanted a truck that felt like a luxury SUV with a bed, this was it. But you paid for the privilege.

my-2026-take-on-the-2021-midsize-pickup-class-image-1

Honda Ridgeline: The Refined Outlier 🚙

If you want something that drives like a car or SUV but has the flexibility of a truck bed, the Ridgeline is easily the most refined option. The cheaper FWD model came with more standard features than the supposedly luxurious Canyon. Fully independent suspension made for a comfortable ride, but—and this is important—it won't help you haul much more than an ATV. Even the AWD version is pretty useless off-road. So if you're the adventurous type, you might want to forget the Honda. Trust me on this one: it's a great truck for suburban life, but not for the wild.

my-2026-take-on-the-2021-midsize-pickup-class-image-2

Nissan Frontier: The Old-School Workhorse 🛠️

There's little doubt the Ridgeline is the most refined; the opposite is true for the Frontier. It was by some distance the oldest model in the class, and it was set to be replaced in 2022. If you're going to be doing more hauling and work, then the back-to-basics nature of this truck should put it at the top of your list. It certainly won't make for the most comfortable daily driver, but it will be a dependable workhorse, able to take more punishment than the more modern trucks. Sometimes, simple is better.

my-2026-take-on-the-2021-midsize-pickup-class-image-3

Chevrolet Colorado: The Budget-Friendly Diesel 🛢️

The Colorado was the most fuel-efficient in diesel guise and did everything else perfectly well, with the added bonus of being more affordable than the other trucks. But with it being more affordable, it lacked a few options. Like its Canyon sister, it lost the manual transmission in 2021. If you chose the diesel, refinement shouldn't be one of your priorities—it was the least refined among all the powerplant options. But it got the job done without breaking the bank.

my-2026-take-on-the-2021-midsize-pickup-class-image-4

Toyota Tacoma: The Fan Favorite with Cracks 🏔️

The Tacoma had a huge fanbase, and it was still a good truck. But there were better options. The competition improved a huge amount, while the Tacoma, for the most part, stayed the same. It also had a few uncharacteristic reliability concerns—something Toyota seemed immune to until Takatagate. What we can't overlook are the good bits: it was one of the best off-road, and possibly the only one that could haul a full load while going off-road too. So if you're a die-hard Tacoma fan, you'll still love it. But if you're shopping with your head, you might look elsewhere.

my-2026-take-on-the-2021-midsize-pickup-class-image-5

Ford Ranger: The Jack of All Trades 🎯

If you want a truck that just does everything well, the Ranger should be pretty high on your list. It's one of those vehicles that isn't the best at anything, but it's just so good at everything it becomes impossible to ignore. It will happily take you pretty much anywhere at the weekend, then get through all the work you need it to do during the week. You only have one powertrain option, but it's solid. And if you're willing to splash out and get the Tremor package, you'll have one of the best off-road trucks on the market. For me, this was the sweet spot.

my-2026-take-on-the-2021-midsize-pickup-class-image-6

Jeep Gladiator: The Adventure Specialist 🏕️

Jeep didn't cheap out when they put the Gladiator into production again—it's essentially a specialty item. This is a true adventure vehicle disguised as a pickup. Although we're sure it can do some work during the week, it's designed for long-term off-grid adventuring. The Gladiator is worth the premium only if that's what you're buying it for. Otherwise, the more affordable trucks are going to be a better bet. You know what they say: horses for courses.

my-2026-take-on-the-2021-midsize-pickup-class-image-7

Ford Ranger Raptor: The One We Waited For 🦖

The current Raptor obviously hadn't made it to the US back then, but with Ford partnering up with VW to make the next-generation Ranger and Amarok, the US was likely to get that version of the Raptor. Named truck of the year for 2020 in pretty much every market it got sold in, the new Ranger Raptor had big boots to fill. Expectations were naturally high. I was pretty excited to see what that truck would look like, and I suspected Ford would announce it within the year. In 2026, we know how that story played out, but back then, it was worth waiting for.

my-2026-take-on-the-2021-midsize-pickup-class-image-8

Quick Comparison Table 📊

Truck Strength Weakness Best For
GMC Canyon Comfort, interior Price, no manual Luxury commuters
Honda Ridgeline Refinement, ride Off-road ability Suburban families
Nissan Frontier Durability, simplicity Age, comfort Workhorse duties
Chevrolet Colorado Fuel efficiency, value Refinement Budget buyers
Toyota Tacoma Off-road, payload Stagnation, reliability Off-road enthusiasts
Ford Ranger All-round competence Not best at anything Everyone
Jeep Gladiator Off-grid adventure Price, on-road manners Adventurers

Final Thoughts 💭

Looking back from 2026, I can see how much the midsize truck segment has evolved. Many of these models have been redesigned or replaced, but the core lessons remain: there's no perfect truck for everyone. You have to pick the one that fits your life. For me, the Ranger stands out as the ultimate compromise—and isn't that what midsize trucks are all about? ... But hey, that's just my two cents. What's your pick?